Login

Cart

Your cart is empty

Gifts under $25

🎁 Holiday Gifts Under $25: Thoughtful & Unique Finds

 

Sticking to your budget doesn't mean sacrificing quality or charm this holiday season! This is your curated guide to finding personalized, artisan gifts and stocking stuffers that feel incredibly special, all for under $25.

Forget the generic gift cards—give something handcrafted and unique that truly shows you care.

Sort by

158 products

Filters
Pittsburgh Italyinz Ornament
Pittsburgh Italyinz Ornament Sale price$14.99
Pittsburgh Yinzer Ornament - Perfect Gift for Steel City Fans
Pittsburgh Yinzer Ornament - Perfect Gift for Steel City Fans Sale price$14.99
Sasquatch Ornament | Bigfoot Collectible | Unique Home DecorSasquatch Ornament | Bigfoot Collectible | Unique Home Decor
Sasquatch Ornament | Bigfoot Collectible | Unique Home Decor Sale price$14.99
Rainbow Bridge Pet Memorial Ceramic OrnamentRainbow Bridge Pet Memorial Ceramic Ornament
Rainbow Bridge Pet Memorial Ceramic Ornament Sale priceFrom $14.99
Show Your Alpha Phi Omega Pride With These Beautiful Ceramic Ornaments | Available in Matching Wine and Jewelry Accessories
Show Your Alpha Phi Omega Pride With These Beautiful Ceramic Ornaments | Available in Matching Wine and Jewelry Accessories Sale price$14.99
South Fayette Lions Ornament - Perfect Gift for any Lion!South Fayette Lions Ornament - Perfect Gift for any Lion!
South Fayette Lions Ornament - Perfect Gift for any Lion! Sale priceFrom $14.99
Air Force Gift - Air Force Ornament- Airmen Gift - Military Ornament - Officially Licensed - Air Force Christmas - Soldier Gift - TrooperAir Force Gift - Air Force Ornament- Airmen Gift - Military Ornament - Officially Licensed - Air Force Christmas - Soldier Gift - Trooper
Top Gun Spirit: Officially Licensed USAF Trooper Ornament (Gift Boxed) Sale priceFrom $14.99
On saleVan Gogh's Starry Night Ceramic Ornament - Personalized Art GiftVan Gogh's Starry Night Ceramic Ornament - Personalized Art Gift
Van Gogh's Starry Night Ceramic Ornament - Personalized Art Gift Sale priceFrom $14.99
Watercolor Bear Christmas Ornament - Unique Holiday DecorWatercolor Bear Christmas Ornament - Unique Holiday Decor
Watercolor Bear Christmas Ornament - Unique Holiday Decor Sale price$14.99
Winter Deer Scene Christmas Ornament Personalized OptionWinter Deer Scene Christmas Ornament Personalized Option
Winter Deer Scene Christmas Ornament Personalized Option Sale priceFrom $14.99
"All I Need is Coffee and My Cat" Mug | Cat Lover Coffee Mug"All I Need is Coffee and My Cat" Mug | Cat Lover Coffee Mug
"All I Need is Coffee and My Cat" Mug | Cat Lover Coffee Mug Sale price$14.99
Dainty Spiral Wrap Crystal RingDainty Spiral Wrap Crystal Ring
Dainty Spiral Wrap Crystal Ring Sale price$14.99
Sun-Kissed Sparkle: Golden Sunflower Dangle Earrings with Glitter ResinSun-Kissed Sparkle: Golden Sunflower Dangle Earrings with Glitter Resin
Sun-Kissed Sparkle: Golden Sunflower Dangle Earrings with Glitter Resin Sale price$14.99
Basketball Hoop Charm Necklace- Basketball MomBasketball Hoop Charm Necklace- Basketball Mom
Basketball Hoop Charm Necklace- Basketball Mom Sale priceFrom $14.99
Dainty Gold Starfish Necklace: Escape to Paradise (Gift Box Included)Dainty Gold Starfish Necklace: Escape to Paradise (Gift Box Included)
Dainty Gold Starfish Necklace: Escape to Paradise (Gift Box Included) Sale price$14.99
70's Bohemian Hippy Mood Bead Necklace | Color Changing | Conversation Starter70's Bohemian Hippy Mood Bead Necklace | Color Changing | Conversation Starter
70's Bohemian Hippy Mood Bead Necklace | Color Changing | Conversation Starter Sale price$15.99
Color
Alpha Phi Omega Keyring Bottle Opener
Alpha Phi Omega Keyring Bottle Opener Sale price$16.99
Ciao Bella Bottle Opener Keychain: Pop Tops in Style (Red or Black)Ciao Bella Bottle Opener Keychain: Pop Tops in Style (Red or Black)
Ciao Bella Bottle Opener Keychain: Pop Tops in Style (Red or Black) Sale price$16.99
Color
Alpha Phi Omega Bottle Opener
Alpha Phi Omega Bottle Opener Sale price$16.99
Dad Beer Bottle Opener KeyringDad Beer Bottle Opener Keyring
Dad Beer Bottle Opener Keyring Sale priceFrom $16.99
Im a Pittsburgh Dad Keyring Bottle Opener
Im a Pittsburgh Dad Keyring Bottle Opener Sale price$16.99
Personalized High School & Club Team Earrings - Show Your School Spirit!
Personalized High School & Club Team Earrings - Show Your School Spirit! Sale price$16.99
Van Gogh Starry Night Keyring Bottle Opener - Artistic Bar AccessoryVan Gogh Starry Night Keyring Bottle Opener - Artistic Bar Accessory
Van Gogh Starry Night Keyring Bottle Opener - Artistic Bar Accessory Sale price$16.99
Yinzer Jagoff Pittsburgh Dad & Fun Themed Keyring Bottle OpenersYinzer Jagoff Pittsburgh Dad & Fun Themed Keyring Bottle Openers
Yinzer Jagoff Pittsburgh Dad & Fun Themed Keyring Bottle Openers Sale price$16.99
Personalized Photo Wedding Anniversary Christmas OrnamentPersonalized Photo Wedding Anniversary Christmas Ornament
Personalized Photo Wedding Anniversary Christmas Ornament Sale priceFrom $16.99
Personalized Watercolor Dog Pet Puppy Ceramic OrnamentPersonalized Watercolor Dog Pet Puppy Ceramic Ornament
Personalized Watercolor Dog Pet Puppy Ceramic Ornament Sale priceFrom $16.99
Sisters Ornament, Pressed Flower Ornament, Sister Gift, Floral OrnamentSisters Ornament, Pressed Flower Ornament, Sister Gift, Floral Ornament
Sisters Ornament, Pressed Flower Ornament, Sister Gift, Floral Ornament Sale price$16.99
Pearl and Crystal Stretch Rings in Assorted Color ChoicesPearl and Crystal Stretch Rings in Assorted Color Choices
Pearl and Crystal Stretch Rings in Assorted Color Choices Sale priceFrom $16.99
Glow in the Dark Bead Choker Necklace on Leather CordGlow in the Dark Bead Choker Necklace on Leather Cord
Glow in the Dark Bead Choker Necklace on Leather Cord Sale price$16.99
Nativity Ornament Gift | Religious Christmas Keepsake & Decor | PersonalizedNativity Ornament Gift | Religious Christmas Keepsake & Decor | Personalized
Nativity Ornament Gift | Religious Christmas Keepsake & Decor | Personalized Sale priceFrom $16.99
Jesus Loves You Support Christmas Ornament Gift | Religious Christmas Keepsake & Decor | PersonalizedJesus Loves You Support Christmas Ornament Gift | Religious Christmas Keepsake & Decor | Personalized
Jesus Loves You Support Christmas Ornament Gift | Religious Christmas Keepsake & Decor | Personalized Sale priceFrom $16.99
Personalized Basketball Ceramic Ornament | Player, Team Gifts, Coach GiftPersonalized Basketball Ceramic Ornament | Player, Team Gifts, Coach Gift
Personalized Basketball Ceramic Ornament | Player, Team Gifts, Coach Gift Sale priceFrom $17.99
Personalized School Mascot Team Spirit Keyring Bottle Opener - Coach Gift - Teacher GiftPersonalized School Mascot Team Spirit Keyring Bottle Opener - Coach Gift - Teacher Gift
Personalized School Mascot Team Spirit Keyring Bottle Opener - Coach Gift - Teacher Gift Sale priceFrom $18.00
Van Gogh's Starry Night Wine Bottle Stopper - Art Lover's GiftVan Gogh's Starry Night Wine Bottle Stopper - Art Lover's Gift
Van Gogh's Starry Night Wine Bottle Stopper - Art Lover's Gift Sale price$18.00
Personalized Sports Fan Team Spirit Gift- Coach Gift - Teacher GiftTeam Spirit Wine Bottle Stopper
Personalized Sports Fan Team Spirit Gift- Coach Gift - Teacher Gift Sale priceFrom $18.00
Asymmetrical Gold Star, Moon, and Saturn Drop EarringsAsymmetrical Gold Star, Moon, and Saturn Drop Earrings
Asymmetrical Gold Star, Moon, and Saturn Drop Earrings Sale price$18.00
NASA Logo Wine Bottle StopperNASA Logo Wine Bottle Stopper
NASA Logo Wine Bottle Stopper Sale price$18.00
Delicate Lucite Flower Single Dangle Earrings with Austrian Crystal | Handmade | Assorted ColorsDelicate Lucite Flower Single Dangle Earrings with Austrian Crystal | Handmade | Assorted Colors
Delicate Lucite Flower Single Dangle Earrings with Austrian Crystal | Handmade | Assorted Colors Sale price$18.00
Color
Elevate Your Look: Stainless Steel Teardrop Gemstone Chain Drop Earrings (Sapphire, Emerald, Gray Crystal)Elevate Your Look: Stainless Steel Teardrop Gemstone Chain Drop Earrings (Sapphire, Emerald, Gray Crystal)
Elevate Your Look: Stainless Steel Teardrop Gemstone Chain Drop Earrings (Sapphire, Emerald, Gray Crystal) Sale price$18.00
Pittsburgh City Scene Wine Bottle Stopper
Pittsburgh City Scene Wine Bottle Stopper Sale price$18.99
Alpha Phi Omega Wine Bottle Stopper
Alpha Phi Omega Wine Bottle Stopper Sale price$18.99
ALPHA PHI OMEGA WINE BOTTLE STOPPER
ALPHA PHI OMEGA WINE BOTTLE STOPPER Sale price$18.99
Bear in the Woods Wine Tote - Stylish and Durable Wine CarrierBear in the Woods Wine Tote - Stylish and Durable Wine Carrier
Bear in the Woods Wine Tote - Stylish and Durable Wine Carrier Sale price$18.99
Camp Quote Reusable Wine BagCamp Quote Reusable Wine Bag
Camp Quote Reusable Wine Bag Sale price$18.99
New York City Wine Bag and Wine Stopper SetNew York City Wine Bag and Wine Stopper Set
New York City Wine Bag and Wine Stopper Set Sale priceFrom $18.99
Personalized Volleyball Ornament - Perfect Gift for any Volleyball Player, Team Gifts, Family or CoachPersonalized Volleyball Ornament - Perfect Gift for any Volleyball Player, Team Gifts, Family or Coach
Personalized Volleyball Ornament - Perfect Gift for any Volleyball Player, Team Gifts, Family or Coach Sale priceFrom $18.99
Deep Red Hoop Earrings
Deep Red Hoop Earrings Sale price$18.99
Enchanting Royal Blue Sea Glass Hoop EarringsEnchanting Royal Blue Sea Glass Hoop Earrings
Enchanting Royal Blue Sea Glass Hoop Earrings Sale price$18.99

Quick Shipping

Enjoy fast shipping on all orders, no matter where you are.

Satisfied or refunded

Shop with confidence. Love it or return it within 30 days.

Top-notch support

Our team is here to help you with any questions.

Secure payments

Your payment details are safe with encrypted checkout.